The Limits of Tax Audit: Between Reliance on Regular Books and Arbitrary Estimated Assessment – A Study in Light of Law No. 91 of 2005 and Administrative Judiciary By: Dr. Ahmed Abdel Wahab El-Saman Certified Public Accountant and Auditor of Joint-Stock Companies

The Limits of Tax Audit: Between Reliance on Regular Books and Arbitrary Estimated Assessment – A Study in Light of Law No. 91 of 2005 and Administrative… The Limits of Tax Audit، A Study in Light of Law No، Ahmed Abdel Wahab El، Stock Companies The Limits of Tax Audit، Stock Companies The Limits of Tax Audit: Between Reliance on Regular Books and Arbitrary Estimated Assessment – A Study in Light of Law No. 91 of 2005 and Administrative Judiciary By: Dr. Ahmed Abdel Wahab El-Saman Certified Public Accountant and Auditor of Joint-Stock Companies Introduction Tax disputes raise a fundamental problem concerning the estimation of net income, as some tax audit officials at tax offices resort to disregarding the books submitted by the taxpayer, citing unsubstantiated assumptions such as "fabrication of books," despite the taxpayer's compliance with organizing them in accordance with established principles, registering them with the Tax Authority, and having them certified by a certified public accountant. This practice not only violates the provisions of the law but also constitutes a serious breach of official duty, especially in light of settled judicial precedents affirming that an audit official may not deviate from regular books except on the basis of concrete and compelling reasons; otherwise, their decision is subject to annulment. First: The Legal Basis for the Obligation to Rely on Books in Self-Assessment of Tax The Income Tax Law No. 91 of 2005 establishes…